.avif)
Dr. Jody Carrington explains how emotional regulation is biologically wired through rhythm and connection and why people need to be shown safety not told what to do.
Emotional safety is the felt sense that you are safe with someone: that you can show what you are feeling without being judged, rushed or told what to do. In this video, best-selling author and speaker Dr. Jody Carrington explains why that sense of safety has to come first when someone is upset, and why calm, steady presence helps more than advice.
Key takeaways
- Emotional regulation is built into us. Dr. Carrington says a regulated adult is "neurobiologically wired" to pick up a crying baby and soothe it with rhythm.
- Our first experience of regulation is rhythmic: the heartbeat of our mothers.
- In distress, people don't need to be told what to do. They need someone to show them calm.
- Safety comes first "so that the prefrontal cortex can come back on and we can start to integrate the experience."
What Dr. Jody Carrington says
Dr. Carrington opens with an image almost anyone can picture. If you came upon a crying infant and you were regulated, she says, "you're neurobiologically wired to pick that baby up," and you would "engage in a rhythmic exchange automatically, even if you never held a baby, because emotional regulation is in our bones."
She traces that instinct back to the very beginning. "The first sound that everybody on this planet hears first, feels first, is the heartbeat of our mamas." Whether or not your mother is still alive or part of your life, she says, "your understanding of emotional regulation is in your bones."
Then she turns to how we help people who are hurting. "What we don't need in times of distress is somebody to tell us what to do. We need somebody to show us." She notes that historically, therapy has often tried to tell people what to do: "Take a deep breath. You're going to be okay." What we haven't done as well, she says, is "show people how to do it" and "create that sense of safety so that the prefrontal cortex can come back on and we can start to integrate the experience."
What does emotional safety look like?
In everyday life, emotional safety looks like being listened to without being interrupted or corrected, having your feelings taken seriously, and trusting that what you share won't be used against you later. It looks like a friend who sits with you instead of rushing to fix things, or a parent who stays calm when a teen comes home upset.
The science lines up with Dr. Carrington's point about rhythm. In one study of mothers and their 3-month-old babies during face-to-face play, mother and infant coordinated their heart rhythms within less than a second, and that match grew stronger during moments of shared emotion and voice (Feldman et al., Infant Behavior and Development). In other words, our bodies tune in to each other during close, face-to-face moments.
How do you respond to someone in emotional distress?
Start with yourself. If you are calm, the other person has something steady to borrow. Then keep it simple: slow your voice, lower your volume, use fewer words and stay close if they want you there. Save problem solving for later.
There's a reason advice doesn't land in the moment. The prefrontal cortex, the brain region behind planning and reasoning, is especially sensitive to stress, and even mild, uncontrollable stress can cause a rapid loss of its abilities (Arnsten, Nature Reviews Neuroscience). That helps explain why "just calm down" rarely works. Once someone feels safe, they can think it through with you. If you need to steady yourself first, try our 5-minute deep breathing exercises, and for parents, see our guide to supporting daughters through anxiety.
If distress is ongoing, or linked to trauma, a doctor or therapist can help. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988 (US).
Video transcript
Transcript (lightly edited for reading):
If you came upon a crying infant around this globe, regardless of age, race, religion, socioeconomic status, or gender identity, if you came upon a crying infant and you were regulated, you're neurobiologically wired to pick that baby up. You can't just be like, "Oh, shoot. I hope somebody gets that one." You would pick that baby up and you would engage in a rhythmic exchange automatically, even if you never held a baby, because emotional regulation is in our bones. The first sound that everybody on this planet hears first, feels first, is the heartbeat of our mamas. Bum bum. The rhythmic exchange from your mama to you. And whether she's alive or you have a relationship with her or not, your understanding of emotional regulation is in your bones. And what we don't need in times of distress is somebody to tell us what to do. We need somebody to show us. Okay. Okay. Okay. And you understand, oftentimes historically in therapy, we're trying to tell people what to do. "Okay. Take a deep breath. You're going to be okay. Okay, let's [unclear]. We'll get over it." And what we haven't done historically really well is to show people how to do it. Okay. Okay. Okay. Create that sense of safety so that the prefrontal cortex can come back on and we can start to integrate the experience.
Common questions
How do you create emotional safety in a relationship?
Listen more than you advise, respond to feelings without judging them, keep confidences, and stay calm during conflict. Repair matters too: when you get it wrong, say so and try again. Safety is built through small, repeated moments, not one big conversation.
Why doesn't telling someone to calm down work?
When someone is flooded with stress, the thinking part of the brain is harder to access, so instructions often feel dismissive. Showing calm through a steady voice and presence gives their nervous system a cue to settle.
What are signs of emotional distress?
Signs can include changes in sleep or appetite, pulling away from people, irritability, crying more than usual, trouble concentrating and losing interest in things that used to matter. If these last more than a couple of weeks, check in with a doctor or therapist.
About the expert: Dr. Jody Carrington is a best-selling author and speaker and the host of the UNLONELY podcast.
Related: It Takes a Village: Why Co-Regulation Actually Works







